Your review will help me in the Webcomic Planet War, but I know it’s an awful lot of work registering for review sites on whatnot. So why not put your reviews right here?
All reviews will be posted below once they have been moderated, with the newest at the top.
“Epic Fail is anything but Fail. From it’s humourous characters, to the situations that they find themselves in, you really can only get Epic Win with this webcomic.
Amy is a joy to not only talk to but work with as well in podcasts, online and of course in the social media circuits like Twitter, Facebook et al.”
Overall Rating = 10
by Kurt Sasso of TGT Webcomics
“On art: Competent art — the style works for the story, and it has good shading.
On writing: I could not get into the story. Within ten pages, my eyes were glazing over as I tried to keep on reading. I didn’t understand any of the characters, I didn’t see anything funny, and I had no reason to keep reading, though I did keep trying. Everything in it that had any chance of being interesting, I had already seen elsewhere done more competently. Nothing struck me as unique, funny, or even “non-cliche.”
Other: No problems with the website, which is set up competently. The updates seem to go up regularly. I really like the “update status” for each new page; that’s a great way to tell readers how close the story is to its next update.
Overall: The writing might work for people who really like this kind of story; I’m not one, so only the very best tend to hook me. The art does not detract from anything, and the website is set up clearly. I don’t think the comic is very good right now, but it might develop into something better later, and if it does, the website will be prepared for it.
I wish the artist good luck in continuing the story. No matter whether it’s good right now, everyone needs to start somewhere, and it might develop into something interesting.”
Overall Rating = 3
“Epic Fail: Its not as funny as Half Assed Chaos, but the pictures are better!”
Overall Rating = 5
By John Seward
“Wierd, witty and very amusing!”
Overall Rating = 10
By an old D&D comrade of Wien1938.wordpress.com